Redudancy between PPOE and Static Interface in Firewall

This articles explains how the FortiGate routes traffic with two static default routes depending on various combination of administrative distance, priority, and if a Policy Based Route is present.Description

Network scenario used for this example :

                     [        FortiGate        ]
[ PC ] -- LAN ------ [ switch           port16 ] --- ISP1 (192.168.182.0/23)
(10.160.0.0/16)      [                  port13 ] --- ISP2 (172.31.224.0/23)


Note : the "priority" parameter is used in situation where a static route needs to be present in order to accept incoming traffic and pass the RPF check (anti-spoofing). Please check related articles for more details.


Preferences :

• Priority preference   : lowest value is preferred for the routing table
• Distance preference : lowest value is preferred for the routing table

Scope

• All FortiGate model
• FortiOS 4.1 and above.
• NAT mode only

Solution

Scenario 1 : same distance , same priority.

Configuration example :


config router static
    edit 1
        set device "port16"
        set gateway 192.168.183.254
    next
    edit 2
        set device "port14"
        set gateway 172.31.225.254
    next
end


The routing table contains the two static routes and ECMP will be applied (See related article about ECMP) :

FGT# get router  info routing-table static

S*      0.0.0.0/0 [10/0] via 172.31.225.254, port13                   [10/0] via 192.168.183.254, port16

Verify egress interface on ping from PC to 10.70.202.225 with a sniffer trace  :

FGT# diagnose  sniffer packet any "icmp" 4

6.748817 switch in 10.160.0.93 -> 10.70.202.225: icmp: echo request 6.748858 port16 out 192.168.182.200 -> 10.70.202.225: icmp: echo request

Scenario 2 : different distance , same priority.

Configuration example :


config router static
    edit 1
        set device "port16"
        set gateway 192.168.183.254
    next
    edit 2
        set device "port13"
        set distance 5
        set gateway 172.31.225.254
    next
end


The routing table contains only the static route with the lowest distance :

FGT# get router  info routing-table static

S*      0.0.0.0/0 [5/0] via 172.31.225.254, port13

Scenario 3a : same distance , different priority.

Configuration example :


config router static
    edit 1
        set device "port16"
        set gateway 192.168.183.254
        set priority 2
    next
    edit 2
        set device "port13"
        set gateway 172.31.225.254
        set priority 5
    next
end


The routing table contains the two static routes but only the one with the lowest priority (port 16) is used for routing traffic. The second one is used to accept traffic ingressing port13.

FGT# get router  info routing-table static

S*      0.0.0.0/0 [10/0] via 192.168.183.254, port16, [2/0]                   [10/0] via 172.31.225.254, port13, [5/0]

Verify egress interface on ping from PC to 10.70.202.225 with a sniffer trace  :

FGT# diagnose sniffer packet  any "icmp" 4

3.518463 switch in 10.160.0.93 -> 10.70.202.225: icmp: echo request 3.518481 port16 out 192.168.182.200 -> 10.70.202.225: icmp: echo request

Scenario 3b : same distance , different priority.

Configuration example :


config router static
    edit 1
        set device "port16"
        set gateway 192.168.183.254
        set priority 2
    next
    edit 2
        set device "port13"
        set gateway 172.31.225.254
        set priority 1
    next
end


The routing table contains the two static routes but only the one with the lowest priority (port 13) is used for routing traffic. The second one is used to accept traffic ingressing port16.

FGT# get router  info routing-table static

S*      0.0.0.0/0 [10/0] via 172.31.225.254, port13, [1/0]                   [10/0] via 192.168.183.254, port16, [2/0]

Verify egress interface on ping from PC to 10.70.202.225 with a sniffer trace  :

FGT# diagnose sniffer packet  any "icmp" 4

2.636176 switch in 10.160.0.93 -> 10.70.202.225: icmp: echo request 2.636222 port13 out 172.31.224.200 -> 10.70.202.225: icmp: echo request

Scenario 4 : same distance , same priority,  policy based route

The goal is to route all HTTP traffic over port13.

Configuration example :


config router static
    edit 1
        set device "port16"
        set gateway 192.168.183.254
    next
    edit 2
        set device "port14"
        set gateway 172.31.225.254
    next
end

config router policy
    edit 1
        set input-device "switch"
        set protocol 6
        set start-port 80
        set end-port 80
        set output-device "port13"
    next
end


Note : no gateway is defined in the Policy Based route above. In this case the FortiGate will lookup the best route in the routing on port13.

The routing table contains the two static routes and ECMP will be applied except for the traffic matching the Policy Based route  routed on port13 :

FGT# get router info routing-table static

S*      0.0.0.0/0 [10/0] via 172.31.225.254, port13                   [10/0] via 192.168.183.254, port16

Scenario 5 : same distance , different priority,  policy based route

The goal is to verify that all HTTP traffic is routed over port13 even though the static route priority in this interface is less preferred than on port 16.

Configuration example :


config router static
    edit 1
        set device "port16"
        set gateway 192.168.183.254
        set priority 2
    next
    edit 2
        set device "port13"
        set gateway 172.31.225.254
        set priority 5
    next
end

config router policy
    edit 1
        set input-device "switch"
        set protocol 6
        set start-port 80
        set end-port 80
        set output-device "port13"
    next
end


Note : no gateway is defined in the Policy Based route above. In this case the FortiGate will lookup the best route in the routing on port13.

The routing table contains the two static routes but only the one with the lowest priority (port 16) is used for routing traffic, except for the traffic matching the Policy Based route which will be routed over port13 : 

FGT# get router info routing-table static

S*      0.0.0.0/0 [10/0] via 192.168.183.254, port16, [2/0]                   [10/0] via 172.31.225.254, port13, [5/0]